As a Lawyer, You Sent the Judge In?

Chapter 428 The source of the false case? What is the truth? !

 What Xiao Chunmei originally stated to Su Bai and Li Xuezhen was—

 In this case, the defendant Li Dong was charged only because the hospital prescribed exorbitant prices for medicines.

Moreover, these drugs are ineffective and cannot alleviate Xiao Chunmei's condition, or even worsen her condition.

 In this case, Li Dong went to the hospital to discuss the matter.

Then the hospital reported him to the Law Enforcement Bureau for causing quarrels and provoking trouble.

 Initiate a public prosecution.

 But what is the actual situation of this case?

 What is the content presented in the dossier?

 The actual situation of this case is completely inconsistent with the content presented in the file and the situation expressed by Xiao Chunmei!

 Even speaking, the gap is very big!

According to the content of the judgment, the actual situation is not simply looking for trouble.

  But other situations are superimposed.

It is clearly recorded in the judgment that Li Dong privately carved his official seal to obtain medical expenses and pay for them.

 Performed fraud on the hospital, amounting to more than 168,000 yuan!

Li Dong was sentenced to three years and six months in prison for picking quarrels, provoking trouble, fraud and other acts.

 Sentenced to three years and six months in prison for several crimes.

 Is this penalty severe?

 It’s not too heavy!

 The dossier contains criminal facts, a complete chain of evidence and actual objective facts.

Based on this situation, should Li Dong be sentenced to three years and six months in prison?

should!

 It is a serious illegal crime to engrave a seal privately to obtain medical expenses and pay for medical expenses.

 Involved in fraud, and the amount has exceeded 100,000.

 It must be a fixed-term imprisonment of more than three years.

  Judging from the file, there are no other circumstances in the judgment of this case, and it is a very authentic judgment result.

.

 ….

 In a hotel room.

Li Xuezhen looked at the file with seriousness written all over her face. Was she deceived by her client?

 When screening short video sources, Li Xuezhen will usually conduct emphatically screening.

 She admitted that among some sources of cases, there would be false cases.

but.…

 So far, she has not screened out a single false case source!

Is this case a false case?

 Judging from the current situation, it is very similar.

Why do you say that?

 Because the actual situation is seriously inconsistent with the situation described by the client!

It is appropriate to have fraudulent behavior but not express it. Do you just want them to help with the entrustment?

only.…

 In this case, they have no need to accept this commission.

 At best, I was just tricked into understanding it.

 Xiao Chunmei, what is the purpose of doing this?

 To tease them?

 Or do you think they will continue to entrust this case under such circumstances?

Li Xuezhen didn't understand Xiao Chunmei's approach, so she asked: "Lawyer Su..."

“Does Xiao Chunmei not know the specific situation, or is she deliberately concealing it?”

“As the defendant, Li Dong obviously made subjective mistakes in his fraud against the hospital!”

“As Xiao Chunmei’s wife, her close relatives should know the verdict, right?”

 “It’s impossible not to know!”

“Xiao Chunmei came to our Baijun Law Firm to help with the lawsuit. When she described the case, she spoke so pitifully...as if she really didn’t know that Li Dong was committing fraud..."

"what is happening?"

 Xiao Li couldn't care less about being in the same room as Su Bai now.

There were too many doubts about this case, which completely aroused her curiosity.

Su Bai shook his head after hearing several questions from Li Xuezhen.

 To be honest, he couldn’t tell exactly what the case was.

Just from his observation, it doesn’t look like Xiao Chunmei is lying.

It's more like I really don't know, I really don't know anything about Li Dong defrauding the hospital.

We can only wait until tomorrow to take the file to the client to understand the situation.

  Or learn more about the situation from the party Li Dong.

 After sorting out the files.

Su Bai turned his head and said:

“The current situation is not certain yet, but what is certain is that Xiao Chunmei may not understand certain circumstances as a party involved.”

 “Don’t worry, just ask tomorrow.”

“Okay, you go back to your room first and get up early tomorrow.”

Li Xuezhen heard Su Bai's words and subconsciously looked down at her outfit.

　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　?)

Lawyer Su, what do you mean?

I came here dressed like this, and Lawyer Su still asked me to go back and get up early tomorrow?

 Get up early tomorrow without affecting your ability to sleep late today!

Su Bai seemed to have noticed what Li Xuezhen was thinking, and did not give Li Xuezhen a chance to speak, so she continued to speak:

"What's wrong?"

 “Is there anything else?”

 “No….No more.”

Li Xuezhen’s face was full of frustration, and she lowered her head and let out a light sigh.

 Then he took some of the neatly arranged files and looked back at Su Bai step by step.

As if thinking of something, Li Xuezhen turned her head and said with joy in her voice:

“Lawyer Su... I think we can continue to discuss this case in depth without having to drive me back to my room.”

 Su Bai: .….

 Your abacus has already fallen into my face!

 “No, let’s wait until tomorrow.”

“Or you can report to me on your mobile phone after you go back to your room.”

 “Oh, good Lawyer Su.”

Lin Xuezhen’s plan failed again, and her face was full of confusion.

When he walked out of the room, he reluctantly closed the door of Su Bai's room.

even.…

Su Bai could vaguely hear Li Xuezhen sighing.

　　　　???”

.

 ….

 The next day, get up early.

Su Bai couldn't help but twitch his lips when he saw Li Xuezhen's slightly irritable expression.

 Xiao Li... was obviously unwilling last night and couldn't sleep well!

but.…

 As long as you know it well.

Su Bai didn't ask too much, but brought Li Xuezhen to Xiao Chunmei's house again.

 At the time when the entrustment agreement was last signed.

Many of the situations stated by Xiao Chunmei are different from those in the dossier.

 The circumstances stated in the dossier will generally not be false, especially when Li Dong is suspected of fraud.

 Because judging from the files, Li Dong was suspected of fraud, which involved the existence of objective, true and effective evidence, and his admission of guilt and punishment.

 It is almost impossible to be forced or unjust.     It's just...

When Su Bai came to Xiao Chunmei with the file and asked about Li Dong's suspected fraud.

 Xiao Chunmei was very surprised.

"What? Li Dong was actually involved in fraud? He carved the official seal privately, and he stole the hospital's money?!"

"how can that be possible!"

“Li Dong said, our family has always had plenty of money. How could he steal money? How could he commit fraud?”

“He has never told me these things...”

Su Bai did not explain, but handed the file to Xiao Chunmei.

 After seeing the contents of the dossier, Xiao Chunmei kept muttering to herself:

 “How could this be the result of the verdict? It’s impossible!”

Hearing this, Su Bai frowned slightly and asked a key question:

“When Li Dong was in the first trial, didn’t you, as a family member, attend the hearing?”

 Xiao Chunmei shook her head: "I didn't..."

“Because I am not in good health and have uremia, when Li Dong was preparing for the first trial, I needed to go to the hospital for dialysis and could not participate at all.”

“I wanted others to tell me what was going on, but no one else was willing to tell me what was going on. They just told me that I had been sentenced to more than three years.”

 Speaking of this, Xiao Chunmei seemed to realize something, looked at Su Bai eagerly, and apologized:

 “Lawyer Su...”

“Lawyer Su, I’m sorry. I really didn’t know that Li Dong would commit fraud, engrave official seals privately, and steal the hospital’s money.”

 “If I really knew, I definitely wouldn’t come to you.”

“I’m sorry, Lawyer Su... I’m very sorry.”

 “It’s causing trouble for you...”

Xiao Chunmei also knows Bai Jun Law Firm and the circumstances under which Lawyer Su Bai usually represents clients.

 In this case, Li Dong obviously did something wrong, and Xiao Chunmei knew it very well.

 So as soon as I learned about it, I apologized to Su Bai.

“Lawyer Su, I didn’t know the real situation in this case from the beginning. Lawyer Su, you can completely terminate the commission.”

 Xiao Chunmei said it very sincerely.

After Su Bai heard Xiao Chunmei's statement, he also knew that there must be something hidden in it.

Xiao Chunmei didn't know the reason at the beginning, so she approached them.

 Subjectively speaking, there is no subjective error on the part of Xiao Chunmei.

 Or on the other hand, did Li Dong really do something wrong?

 It is indeed against the law to engrave the hospital seal privately and defraud medical expenses.

But why did Li Dong defraud medical expenses?

The fraudulent medical expenses here are not to make money from the hospital, but to tell the hospital that he has already paid for the drugs.

 Get medicines from the hospital.

From this point of view, it is obvious that Li Dong was allowed to do this because Li Dong could not afford the expensive drugs prescribed by the hospital.

 Is the hospital at fault?

 The hospital prescribed some expensive medicines that had no effect on Xiao Chunmei's condition and did not inform her.

Even frequently deceiving clients and replacing expensive drugs, is this considered the hospital’s fault?

It definitely counts.

 So from a subjective point of view, Li Dong's behavior is more likely to be forced.

but!

Again.

 At the legal level, speculation cannot be used as the basis for facts.

Whether Li Dong was forced to engrave a seal privately to defraud the hospital of medical expenses?

 It still needs to be understood from the words of the parties concerned and the actual objective situation.

  Take this case for example.

Xiao Chunmei found Baijun Law Firm to entrust her. Was her intention good at the beginning?

 It must be good!

Does she want to help her husband reduce his sentence and thinks that her husband has suffered a lot of persecution in this case?

 Same yes!

 Subjectively speaking, there is nothing wrong with Xiao Chunmei’s approach.

 But what are the objective facts?

 The objective fact is that Xiao Chunmei did not even know what punishment Li Dong had committed.

  I didn’t even know that Li Dong had committed fraud.

 So from this point of view, it is very necessary to conduct objective fact investigation.

In this case, Su Bai subjectively believed that Li Dong’s case might have a deeper hidden secret.

 Hence, Xiao Chunmei’s request to cancel the case was not agreed to.

Instead, he said: "We have conducted a rough investigation of this case and have now entrusted it."

“As for whether to cancel the commission, further understanding is needed.”

“We need to meet Li Dong, your husband, to decide whether to cancel the commission for this case.”

Hearing this, Xiao Chunmei's eyes flashed with a hint of surprise: "Lawyer Su..."

 “You really don’t want to cancel the commission of this case?”

“But...this case was entrusted by me because I didn’t understand the situation at the beginning and asked Lawyer Su to come over.”

“I have deceived Lawyer Su.”

 “Lawyer Su...”

 Xiao Chunmei wanted to continue talking.

Su Bai also knew what Xiao Chunmei wanted to say, which was nothing more than an apology.

Xiao Chunmei can just keep these words in her heart, there is no need to say them out on the spot.

So Su Bai interrupted with a smile: "I know."

"But this case... I have read the files carefully, and I am still very interested in this case."

  “Let’s talk about it.”

“As I said just now, whether to cancel the commission or not, I still need to see Li Dong.”

Although Xiao Chunmei knew what Su Bai meant, she still said very gratefully: "Thank you, Lawyer Su..."

.

 ….

After leaving Xiao Chunmei's house, Su Bai took a deep breath.

Li Xuezhen on the side said in confusion: "Lawyer Su..."

“It seems that Xiao Chunmei really doesn’t know what her husband Li Dong has done.”

“Are we continuing to entrust this case?”

Su Bai did not directly answer Li Xuezhen’s question.

 Instead, he repeated what he had just said to Xiao Chunmei.

“To be specific, we still need to meet Li Dong to determine whether Li Dong’s subjective behavior at that time was intentional.”

“If Li Dong’s subjective behavior is to avoid medical expenses, then we cannot entrust this case.”

"But...if there is another secret...you can accept the commission."

“After all… Judging from the current situation, Li Dong’s subjective behavior is good, after all, it is for his wife.”

“If Li Dong acted in a helpless situation, the sentence of three years and six months in prison would be a bit harsh.”

"do you understand?"

Li Xuezhen nodded in understanding, and after a few seconds, she smiled and said:

“I understand, Lawyer Su!”

.

 ….

 PS: Please give me a monthly ticket~

 (End of this chapter)